She may be telling the truth , or she may be hiding the fact that she just wasn't all that into him, but that he was so deserving but she, like a good percentage of women, don't like guys who are too perfect and too nice....hahaha There's no challenge, the pressure is high, and well, the sexual energy is not there...LOL
There's a old wise man's proverb that says "women only respect and appreciate nice guys when women reaches 60 and beyond" hahaha