I was wondering if this is true? Correct me if I am wrong, but I know the San Miao came after the Chu. I believe we have 3 dynasty that has fallen, which Chi You, Chu, and the San Miao.
First of all, you need to get your
CHRONOLOGY straight so that in making these kinds of baseless supposition, you will at least sound somewhat informed/educated -- and of sound mind. Otherwise, those who know (and have researched) sound scholarships will simply
at your
... kekeke ...
(Based on your incoherent
CHRONOLOGY, it would seem (and is most evident) your elementary knowledge/info is most likely rooted/based on Wiki, internet sites/forums, Western/Eastern Hmong/Miao hearsay, and the motley of Utube videos peppered throughout the web like fairy dusts ...
)
Secondly, there is/are
NO CONCLUSIVE evidence, facts, data (historical or modern presentday research/records) to show, suggest, or most importantly PROVE that any and all 3 states; Chu, San Miao, and Chi You is Hmong whatsoever. That is purely speculative. Why? Mainly and simply because it is a KNOWN FACT that none of them, these 3 states, are Chinese (Han or Manchu) period whatsoever. Just because they ARE NOT Chinese does not make them Hmong though, by default. That logic/rationale is ridiculous to say the least. And especially with regards to the Chu State/Kingdom; it is without a doubt, and is believed/accepted by Western and Eastern scholars alike globally that it definitely IS NOT Chinese (Han or Manchu). Again, that does not make it Hmong whatsoever either. (Yes, all of this is based/rooted in historical and modern research/records/scholarships that anyone can easily research versus hearsay, or Internet mumbo-jumbo.)
Lastly, I highly recommend (suggest) any of you who is remotely interested in Hmong/Miao studies/history,
to excercise some common sense and a bit of proactive researching yourselves; NOT purely vest whatever you think you know in/on Internet whatever etc., to get a better understanding and more well-rounded knowledgebase first and foremost versus making these types of borderline idiotic rants ... KEKEKE ...
HINT: In its
CORRECT chronology; the 3 states (or kingdoms) are 1. Chi You (who fought against and lost to Huangdi and Yangdi), 2. San Miao, and 3. the Chu State/Kingdom during the Warring States Era, popularized in a video game called "Romance of the 3-Kingdoms" among other name/titles. (Heck! Even Jet Li's movie, "Hero", touched on this time period, if you knew/had known your Chinese aniquity.)
*** And "NO", the Hmong/Mong word/appellation "Txiv Yawg" does not equate to "Chi You" whatsoever. Any half intellect (of sound mind) Hmong/Mong can make the same argument that "Tsis Yog" equates to "Chi You" ... KEKEKE ...