Sorry but your contradiction just simply doesn't stand...
There is no reason that a person can't play both rules
You can't play two contradicting rules, period. That's saying we allow kicking oh wait we don't allow kicking...so which is it? Or one side does side out scoring and the other side does rally scoring...pick one. Unless you mean I'm already living proof of it, since I went from Hmong rules, to NCAA, to USAV, to FIVB, and AVP Beach rules. So I've basically played five different rules, but never together since they contradict on certain rules.
They are simply different games. And1 vs. New NBA vs. Old NBA vs. Golden Age NBA
I have no idea where you're going with this. It's like NCAA D1, vs NCAA D2 vs NCAA D3 or something. If you call it a different game...you are in the minority of opinion there. Nobody is gonna play D1 format with 20 yrs old rule against another D1 format with up to date rules. If one insists on playing 20 yrs old rule, then slap the label "incomplete" or "incompetent." You can't cheat, period...too many officials watching.
Also, as difficult as it is for a Hmong person to come play NCAA, it will also be a challenge for a person playing NCAA rules to come play Hmong rules
Not really if Hmong rules were actually written and shared before playing. Ever been to a practice where the coach says...no overhand passing on next scrimmage...yo
u all need to work on your bumps? Again trying to prove a point with cheating Hmong rules...oh wait if it was written down...then the cheating may actually not happens...wish
ful thinking but Hmong rules and cheating players are just kind of in the same bag.
I have to disagree with your assessment of players
You disagree with my assessment of players is like saying you disagree with the assessment of players in NCAA, USAV, FIVB, AVP...And the rules are proof of it as well. I didn't make these rules up nor did I assess their skill levels...They're done and "incomplete" and "incompetent" maybe just your nature to nag and try to disprove it as an opinion. I'm telling you facts of some things that can be comparable from player to referee to coach through the progression of volleyball skill levels. You'll just don't go pro level from high school level. And I don't know how to explain it any further unless someone has played by all the different levels of players, by the different levels of rules, and by seeing it from all three different pov's. Players, coaches, and refs will always disagree on things, but when you've been in all three positions long enough...you will connect the dots of comparison. High School/Hmong rules is really at the bottom of the competition skill levels. If some vball player from a big10 D1 team comes out and say...High School (NFHS) is superior...the
y may as well drop out of college right there.
Look at it this way
High School/Hmong rules: Amateur, intermediate, basic
NCAA rules: advance, Semi-Pro
USAV FIVB BEACH: Semi-Pro, Pro levels
The rules follows it, the underlying progression of skill levels...The more advance players they get more rules and more strategies to work with. An amateur player to a Pro Beach player is "incompetent" to step onto the pro court level. Don't get me wrong...one can be competent at their skills level, and still be incompetent to the next skill level. The amateur player is "incomplete" since they've probably never obtained the skill level to fully play as a complete player in all aspect of serving, passing, setting, blocking, and spiking. By now one can't cheat like how they do with Hmong rules.
"There has never been once in the rule that a players's hand must be together, overhand or underhand."
Like I said
not mistaken...I'm gonna believe a real officiating ref from the Pro levels who knows the other rules, over that of just some player whose only grounds are amateur rules (skill levels). 50 years is a lot of rule changes...
9.2.3.2 At the first hit of the team, the ball may
contact various parts of the body con-
secutively, provided that the contacts oc-
cur during one action.This rule specifically states that a player CAN double hit as long as it is one motion
No one can double hit...double hit is two separate motions. Don't twist the words. To a ref, the ball may make multiple contacts. Like I said...be a real ref by the rule. You tell a good ref you double hit it...you just lost the rally. You tell a bad ref you double hit it...well bad ref will probably say play on. But we gonna have a real good corrective chat with that bad ref...later. Again I'm not mistaken.
Everyone is entitled to like whichever rules they want.
How can you state that?
No these rules are not just some simple self entitle want or don't want. They are official. If you can't play by those rules on those competition levels...you are then as "incomplete" and therefore "incompetent" on those higher levels. It doesn't make you inferior...jus
t haven't got there yet. When are you gonna realize that I'm not limiting the scope to just Hmong volleyball rules, old school vs new school. When the officiating rules are changing about every 4 yrs. I believe 8 yrs for FIVB. Old school is very old school. And we're just throwing words around now...
Again...I'm glad the Hmong volleyball is trying to catch up and adopt some of the more current official rules.