Overall, the quality, freshness and taste of their lobsters is on par with the ones I've had at Boom Town and Jackson Rancheria but cost about twice as much. Therefore, will not repeat...
Between Palms' AYCE and Caesar's Bacchannal, Bacchannal's food are much fresher and taste better IMO. Even though Bacchannal's entry fee is $15 more, I would still rather go to there...
With that said, AYCE seemed to do pretty well. Here's a photo I took of their club member's side and still a good line:
And on the non-member side:
Probably why Palms decided to do lobsters on Wednesday only..