From only the quotes, it's too difficult to say who is right or wrong, or if both are right or wrong. There are too many situations to account for.
Generally speaking though, you don't lead someone 5 feet unless it's a play everyone knows, and that usually excludes pickup games. 5 feet is kinda far; the receiving player should be moving or pinning. For a 6 footer, 5 feet is about two steps away. If you're standing on the wing waiting for a catch and shoot, taking 2 steps to get the ball seems unreasonable. Even taking one step for a catch and shoot is too much. The pass should be dead on so the sharp shooter can do his thing.
A good pass depends on the game. Being a good passer means understanding the game you're playing and the people you're playing with. If you're playing with a big jumper, you should be lobbing it. That's a good pass. Making the same pass with someone who can't jump is a bad pass.
Amatuer as in... never played any organized sports... as in only like black top basketball, etc etc...
Organized as in... well like schools and stuff like that with ref's and jersey's and set schedules witch coaches and practices etc etc.....not talking about leagues or tournaments either...
I'm the amatuer and my friend's the organized..
I think it's funnie, we both think that we're the better passer and the other one is the worser.
every now and then we play ball together... we've only met for like a year now and don't know each other's game at all. Different basketball backgrounds
Me: You can't pass the ball.
Him: YOu can't pass the ball.
Me: your passes never on target, it's like arm length away.
Him: What are you talking about? I always lead you to the basket.
Him: You're suppose to run through.
Me: Well if I'm standing why are you throwing the ball 4-5 feet away from me?
Me: You're a horrible passer.
Him: Me? You're always trying to pass it into traffic.
and the debate goes on and on and on...
Different strokes for Different folks I guess.
Who's to say who's right and who's wrong, we just have a different way of thinking and playing when it comes to bball.